The Great Retail Reset: How Economic Pressures Are Rewiring Shopper Behavior
We’re witnessing a fundamental shift in shopper behavior. With inflation continuing to impact household budgets, consumers aren’t just changing what they buy – they’re transforming their purchasing decisions entirely.
Our latest research reveals that shoppers are developing increasingly sophisticated strategies to manage their grocery spending. What’s particularly fascinating isn’t just what they’re doing – it’s why they’re doing it, and how these decisions vary dramatically across different product categories.
The New Trip Mission: Regular is the New Normal
The data tells a compelling story: Regular Trips are on the rise while One-Off Trips (including Replenishment) are declining across the omnichannel shopping environment. Our videometrics show in-store retailers experiencing a 27% increase in Regular Trips compared to 2022, while eCommerce has seen a 19% jump during the same period. This shift signals a deeper change in consumer psychology. Rather than making larger, less frequent shopping trips, consumers are opting for more frequent, smaller basket trips – allowing them to hunt for deals, spread out expenditures, and capitalize on the best value opportunities as they arise.
Why does this matter? Because it fundamentally changes how brands need to position themselves on shelf. When shoppers visited stores primarily for one-off or replenishment trips, brand recognition and habit played outsized roles in purchase decisions. Now, with more regular trips, each shelf interaction represents a new moment of truth – a fresh opportunity for brands to win (or lose) the sale.
The Decline of Planned Purchases: Value Exploration Takes Center Stage
Perhaps most telling is the dramatic decline in planned purchases. In 2022, our data showed that 5 in 10 purchases were planned in advance. By 2024, that number dropped by 20%, representing millions of purchase decisions now up for grabs at the shelf.
What’s filling this gap? Value exploration. Shoppers increasingly arrive at stores with general category needs in mind but deliberately keep their brand options open. As one shopper in our study commented, “I really like the [Private Label] brand; those work just fine. So, that’s what I am looking for today.” This represents a stark contrast from the 2022 mindset reflected in comments like: “The brand I’m looking for is Brand X. I’ve gotten these before, and they work really well.”
The Walkaway Challenge: Why Shoppers Abandon Purchase Intentions
Despite the increase in regular shopping trips, we’re also seeing a concerning trend: category walkaway rates have nearly doubled since 2022 (+1.9x). This means that consumers are approaching the shelf with intent to buy but leaving without making a purchase far more frequently than before.
Our research reveals where these walkaway shoppers go:
- 80% plan to visit a different retailer
- 20% delay their purchase to find a better price, deal, or specific item unavailable during their current trip
This represents a critical challenge for brands and retailers alike. When shoppers walk away, the immediate sale is lost, and there’s a significant risk they’ll find an alternative solution elsewhere, potentially establishing new purchasing habits that exclude your brand entirely.
The Promotion Paradox: More Interest, Less Conversion
One might expect that promotional effectiveness would increase in an inflationary environment. Our data reveals a more nuanced reality: while promo breakthrough has risen by 12% since 2022 (meaning shoppers are noticing more promotions), actual conversion on those promotions has declined by 8%. This creates a frustrating scenario for brands investing in promotional activities. The key insight? When everyone is on sale, no one is on sale. Shoppers are actively seeking deals, but in a sea of yellow tags and discount banners, price reductions alone no longer drive purchase decisions. Our research shows that brands that combine competitive pricing with compelling value propositions—whether through product innovation, enhanced packaging, or solution-based merchandising—break through the promotional clutter. While shoppers notice more promotions during their trips, they’re increasingly selective about which ones actually make it into their carts, demonstrating that in today’s retail environment, winning requires more than just slashing prices.
The Private Label Evolution: From Compromise to Preference
One of the most compelling trends we’ve uncovered is the evolving relationship between shoppers and private label products. A deep dive into the Pet Category revealed a clear correlation between quality perception and purchase intent, but this relationship isn’t uniform across all categories.
For example, we found that private label penetration varies dramatically by subcategory in pet food. While private label kibble has made significant inroads, premium wet food formats remain dominated by national brands. The key differentiator? Perceived risk and emotional connection to the purchase decision. When pet owners view a product as directly impacting their pet’s health and happiness (as with main meal options), they’re less willing to “risk” a private label alternative. However, for supplementary items like treats or accessories, the value proposition of private labels becomes much more compelling.
This pattern repeats across retail, with private label success varying dramatically by aisle and category. Understanding these category-specific nuances is essential for brands developing defensive strategies against private label encroachment.
In-Store vs. E-commerce: Different Challenges, Shared Solutions
While both in-store (+27%) and e-commerce (+19%) channels are experiencing growth in regular trips, the dynamics of each present unique challenges and opportunities.
In-store shoppers display more exploratory behavior, with our videometrics showing increased aisle browsing and product comparison. This makes in-store merchandising innovations, like improved new item call-outs, hot zones for trendy/seasonal SKUs, and dedicated solution sections, particularly effective.
E-commerce shoppers, meanwhile, show higher price sensitivity and greater willingness to compare across multiple retailers. Competitive pricing and strong digital shelf presentation are critical for online success.
However, both channels share a common challenge – providing clear value communication that justifies the price premium of national brands over private label alternatives.
Impulse Purchase Evolution: Different Triggers, Same Opportunity
Despite economic pressures, impulse purchases haven’t disappeared – they’ve evolved. Traditional impulse drivers like end-cap displays and checkout line placements still work, but their effectiveness has diminished as shoppers become more deliberate in their purchasing decisions.
What’s working now? Our research shows three emerging impulse purchase motivators:
- Solution-based merchandising: Products that clearly solve multiple problems or needs
- Perceived scarcity: Limited-time offerings that create urgency
- Value-added bundling: Combinations that deliver more perceived value than individual purchases
Brands that realign their impulse strategies to these new motivators are finding success even in the current challenging environment.
Strategic Imperatives for Brands and Retailers
How should brands and categories react to these evolving shopper behaviors? Our research points to three key strategic imperatives:
- Categories need to focus on merchandising to be more appealing for shoppers who are open to further exploration. This means improved new item call-outs, hot zones for trendy/seasonal SKUs, and dedicated solution sections that make value comparison easier.
- Brands need to consider whether they have the right assortment, from super premium to value, to drive more effective browsing and better stand-out at shelf with ‘Regular Trip’ shoppers.
- Promotions, especially Temporary Price Reductions (TPRs), should be optimized to drive higher conversion and reduce walkaway rates. This means moving beyond simple discounting to creating promotions that deliver genuine perceived value.
Understanding Category-Specific Nuances
What makes our research particularly valuable is how it reveals the interconnectedness of these trends. It’s not enough to look at purchase data alone. The real insights come from understanding the layers of shopper behavior – what they notice, what they consider, what goes in their cart. Our unique Nailbiter videometrics methodology captures authentic shopper behavior in real-time, revealing essential nuances that traditional approaches miss. We’ve uncovered a complex truth through thousands of “in-the-moment” insights – while economic pressures are universal, shopper responses are anything but uniform.
Understanding these nuances – and how they apply specifically to your category – isn’t just helpful; it’s essential for maintaining and growing market share in today’s challenging retail environment. It’s the difference between getting research done and creating a competitive advantage for your products, your category, and your brand.
Turning Challenge Into Opportunity
The current inflationary environment presents real challenges for brands and retailers. But within these challenges lie opportunities for those who adapt strategically.
By understanding the shift toward regular shopping trips, the decline in planned purchases, the evolving role of private labels, and the changing dynamics of promotional effectiveness, brands can develop targeted strategies that address the specific needs of today’s value-conscious consumer.
The key is recognizing that while economic pressures may be universal, consumer responses are highly category-specific. Brands that leverage detailed shopper insights to develop category-specific strategies will survive and thrive in retail’s new normal.
Want the full report on consumer behavior in the face of inflationary pressures and private label trends? Contact Nailbiter today to discover how our videometrics can help you understand the “why” behind changing shopper behavior in your specific category.
Contact Us