There’s a version of the Gen Z shopper story that brands love to tell. They’re impulsive. They’re influenced by TikTok. They’re visual, viral, and volatile. Get the right creator, the right aesthetic, the right moment — and they’re yours.
The behavioral data tells a different story.
Gen Z shoppers are, in fact, among the most planned shoppers in the store. They arrive knowing what they want, where they’ll find it, and having already decided which retailer has earned their trust. By the time they’re standing in front of your product, they’re not exploring. They’re executing.
That’s not the profile of a shopper who’s easy to intercept.
The Consideration Set Is Getting Smaller
Here’s what makes this generation genuinely different from the cohorts that came before: they notice less. Not because they’re disengaged — but because they’re focused. Older generations tend to browse. They choose a retailer for convenience, arrive with a loose plan, and let price guide their in-store decisions. Gen Z inverts that pattern almost entirely. They select their retailer based on perceived value and trust in pricing before they walk in — and once they’re inside, price recedes as a driver. Other factors take over. But the window to influence them is narrow, and it’s getting narrower.
The implication for brands is significant: you don’t just need to be on their list. You need to understand what gets you on their list, because at the shelf, your opportunity to make the case is smaller than it has ever been.
Private Label Has Grown Up — And Gen Z Grew Up with It
The more urgent conversation is about private label. And it’s not the one brands are used to having.
For most of retail history, private label was a price story. You bought store brand because you were watching your wallet. You might feel a little embarrassed about it. You’d go back to your regular brand when times were better.
Gen Z doesn’t experience private label that way at all. They grew up in a world where Kirkland Signature was already a household name, where Good & Gather sat on design-forward shelves alongside national brands, where private selection at Kroger felt premium. To them, these aren’t discount options. They’re trusted brands — and in some categories, they’re the first choice.
What’s particularly telling is why Gen Z buys private label when they do. They’re not reaching for it because it’s cheap. They’re choosing it because of the brand itself. They trust it. That’s a fundamentally different competitive dynamic than anything CPG brands have had to navigate before.
And it varies. Kirkland earns deep trust. Members Mark earns it too. But not every private label tier at every retailer carries the same weight — and the delta between what’s trusted and what’s not within a single retailer can be significant. Brands need to know exactly which tier they’re competing against, not just which retailer they’re in.
The Category Question Brands Aren’t Asking Loudly Enough
Here’s where it gets complicated — and where generic Gen Z strategy starts to break down.
The behaviors described above play out very differently depending on the category. Gen Z’s trust in private label extends surprisingly far — including into OTC healthcare, where you might expect brand loyalty to be more entrenched. Yet in pet care, that same trust evaporates. They won’t take chances with their pets in a way they will with themselves. That tells you something important about how this generation assigns trust, and it should make every brand think carefully about what the equivalent dynamic looks like in their specific aisle.
Novelty still matters to Gen Z — arguably more than to older generations. A new claim, a new format, a distinctive packaging choice can create a pattern interrupt even for a planned shopper. But novelty has to be earned. A line extension that doesn’t feel genuinely different won’t register. And if a brand tries to be everything at once, it’ll land as nothing.
The brands that will win with Gen Z are the ones that resist the urge to throw everything at the wall. This generation responds to one or two things done right — not five things done adequately. The challenge is knowing which one or two things those are in your category, with your shopper, at your retailer.
Curious what videometrics can do for your brand?
The Right Question Is the Starting Point
Brands that approach Gen Z as a monolith will keep getting the wrong answers. The insights that move the needle are specific: What does consideration look like in your category? Which private label tiers are actually competing for your shopper? What creates Notice at the shelf for this cohort — and what converts that Notice to Cart?
Those answers don’t come from generational trend reports. They come from watching real shoppers make real decisions, in real stores, in real time.
That’s exactly where we start.